I’m in a lot of pain. I’ve been a supporter of Israel for all my adult life. I think Israel’s claim to that area is just as legitimate as that of the Palestinians. The partition of Palestine and the establishment of Israel was followed almost immediately by the attacks of the Arab neighboring states. Palestinians left mostly–some were driven out by the kind of atrocities which happen in all wars, but most left, relying on the promises of the Arab countries. Moreover, Israelis were also driven out of through atrocity as well. In fact more Jews were displaced in Arab and Muslim countries than Palestinians in Palestine.
It also seems to me that the evidence is very clear. Hamas started the most recent Gaza conflict. Investigators have been regularly finding justification for Israel’s attacks on schools and other supposedly neutral facilities as they uncover caches of Hamas rockets and other weapons hidden in private residences, hospitals and schools. Hamas continues to pursue the goal of driving all Israelis into the Mediterranean and continues to state that ALL Jews are to be killed. Even some Arab countries are supporting Israel’s fight against both Hamas and Hezbolleh.
All of that is true and much more. But it is not a justification for the policies of Israel against West Bank Palestinians. Today, the latest land grab was declared. You can read the facts in this article from Reuters through Huffington Post. The “Settlements” are an abomination. The right-wing policies of Netanyahu are destroying Israeli credibility and fueling the delegitimacy movement.
The whole Settlement movement is the recipient of 100s of millions of dollars from US pseudo-Christians who call themselves Christian Zionists. There is no justification for this kind of exploitation. It is time to put an end to supporting the Israeli right. They are as bereft of moral standing as the right is in the US.
Sure it pains me to have to say all this. I have Israeli friends and colleagues whom I love. I continue to support their right to exist in that place, but not the continued theft of Palestinian lands nor the treatment Palestinians receive from the Conservative, Right-wing, UltraOrthodox Israeli government. I could not maintain my own integrity if I don’t speak out.
By Jeffrey Heller
JERUSALEM, Aug 31 (Reuters) – Israel announced on Sunday a land appropriation in the occupied West Bank that an anti-settlement group termed the biggest in 30 years, drawing Palestinian condemnation and a U.S. rebuke.
Some 400 hectares (988 acres) in the Etzion Jewish settlement bloc near Bethlehem were declared “state land, on the instructions of the political echelon” by the military-run Civil Administration.
“We urge the government of Israel to reverse this decision,” a State Department official said in Washington, calling the move “counterproductive” to efforts to achieve a two-state solution between Israel and the Palestinians.
Israel Radio said the step was taken in response to the kidnapping and killing of three Jewish teens by Hamas militants in the area in June.
Tensions stoked by the incident quickly spread to Israel’s border with Gaza, which is controlled by Hamas, and the two sides engaged in a seven-week war that ended on Tuesday with an Egyptian-brokered ceasefire.
The notice published on Sunday by the Israeli military gave no reason for the land appropriation decision.
Peace Now, which opposes Israeli settlement activities in the West Bank, territory the Palestinians seek for a state, said the appropriation was meant to turn a site where 10 families now live adjacent to a Jewish seminary into a permanent settlement.
Construction of a major settlement at the location, known as “Gevaot”, has been mooted by Israel since 2000. Last year, the government invited bids for the building of 1,000 housing units at the site.
Peace Now said the land seizure was the largest announced by Israel in the West Bank since the 1980s and that anyone with ownership claims had 45 days to appeal. A local Palestinian mayor said Palestinians owned the tracts and harvested olive trees on them.
Israel has come under intense international criticism over its settlement activities, which most countries regard as illegal under international law and a major obstacle to the creation of a viable Palestinian state in any future peace deal.
Nabil Abu Rdainah, a spokesman for Western-backed Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, called on Israel to cancel the appropriation. “This decision will lead to more instability. This will only inflame the situation after the war in Gaza,” Abu Rdainah said.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu broke off U.S.-brokered peace talks with Abbas in April after the Palestinian leader reached a reconciliation deal with Hamas, the Islamist movement that dominates the Gaza Strip.
In a series of remarks after an open-ended ceasefire halted the Gaza war, Netanyahu repeated his position that Abbas would have to sever his alliance with Hamas for a peace process with Israel to resume.
The administration of President Barack Obama, who has been at odds with Netanyahu over settlements since taking office in 2009, pushed back against the land decision. It was the latest point of contention between Washington and its top Middle East ally Israel, which also differ over Iran nuclear talks.
“We have long made clear our opposition to continued settlement activity,” said the State Department official, who declined to be identified.
“This announcement, like every other settlement announcement Israel makes, planning step they approve and construction tender they issue, is counterproductive to Israel’s stated goal of a negotiated two-state solution with the Palestinians,” the official said.
After the collapse of the last round of U.S.-brokered peace talks, U.S. officials cited settlement construction as one of the main reasons for the breakdown, while also faulting the Palestinians for signing a series of international treaties and conventions.
Israel has said construction at Gevaot would not constitute the establishment of a new settlement because the site is officially designated a neighborhood of an existing one, Alon Shvut, several km (miles) down the road.
Some 500,000 Israelis live among 2.4 million Palestinians in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, territory that the Jewish state captured in the 1967 Middle East war. (Reporting by Jeffrey Heller in Jerusalem, Matt Spetalnick in Washington and Ali Sawafta in Ramallah; Editing by Mark Heinrich and Andrea Ricci)